I was just telling my wife how cool real estate agent apple butter is, and how random apple butter is the best, and decided to google it to see if anyone else was waxing nostalgic about this phenomenon, and I find....this. 
Rest assured, more people are happy to see random apple butter than not, and I can also assure you that your local food pantry would gladly accept it. If it helps, just imagine it's peanut butter...but made of apples.